About the Book:
This long-awaited novel by the author of The House at Riverton begins with a long lost letter. Its contents compel young Edie Burchill to journey to the eerie realm of Millderhurst Castle, where her mother, then just 13 years old, waited out the London Blitz. What Edie learns about those distant hours in that faraway place will forever change her view of her mother and herself. A subtle, artfully constructed story about place, the past, and time’s reverberations.
Book Review:
I have to admit that after reading The Forgotten Garden I had a lot of expectations for this book. After all, I fell in love with that one — so I was expecting another opportunity to get lost in a book — and want the world to go away. And to a certain extent this book fulfilled expectations. But somehow I came away from this one feeling like some of the magic was missing that made the other book so fun to read. Consequently I felt like this book was more of an effort to get through.
For some reason it was the characters that just didn’t quite work for me in this book. I just felt like there wasn’t as much depth as I have come to expect from Ms. Morton’s characters — which left me feeling like something was missing from the whole story. Edie just didn’t seem to be all that engaged with the world around her. She didn’t have much in the way of curiosity, in the face of the building mystery throughout the story. So for that reason, the main person looking for the answers never really seemed to get all that involved in the story, from the beginning. Combine that with the sisters, who are obviously not what they appear to be, even from the very beginning of the book — and I just came away feeling like there was quite a bit of a let down where this story was concerned.
On the positive side, however. The story is very well conceived — and it really was intriguing. Revolving around the mysterious book written by an illusive author, The Mud Man is rumored to be surrounded with myriad questions, and intense debate on how much, if any of the book is grounded in reality. Add to that the compelling historical setting of the back story — in World War II, during the bombing of London, not to mention the creepy castle setting that is just this side of collapse, and is perfectly adapted to the stuff of nightmares — and you really have the makings for a great story. And I think this one would have delivered much more if the characters had been a little stronger in the development. But I can’t fault the story line, and I love the creativity demonstrated by Ms. Morton in pulling together various story lines, and building them into one cohesive whole.
The over all thing that I think drove me crazy about this book was simply the unasked questions that continue to skulk in between the lines of each page. The mysterious letter, that Edie fails to ask her mother about, the questions about the past, and failure to engage the sisters on a more personal, and even intimate level — it all made for a frustrating read. There just seemed to be something about the whole thing that was off. And I know this was a mystery. But for some reason, it just didn’t flow smoothly for me, and I felt like every page was more of an effort that an adventure.
For more information about this book, and its author be sure to visit the following websites:
When you buy a product (not just books – any product), via one of my links, The Book Worm’s Library earns income from the sale and as always, it’s much appreciated as all affiliate income is used to support the blog by contributing to giveaways, postage, travel, and attending book industry related events. We appreciate all those that help to support our blog, and have provided links below for the direct links to this book.
Originally posted 2011-01-20 07:00:28. Republished by Blog Post Promoter



Home

















